When it comes to robot vacuums, two names consistently dominate the conversation: iRobot Roomba and Shark. Both brands offer a wide range of models, from basic bots to high-tech cleaning machines. But which one is actually better? Is the original Roomba still king, or has Shark stolen the crown?
As someone who's tested models from both camps, I can tell you there's no single "best" brand – it depends entirely on your priorities, budget, and home environment. Let's break down the key differences and similarities between Roomba and Shark in 2025 to help you decide.
Navigation Technology: Seeing vs. Mapping
This is one of the biggest historical differentiators, though the lines are blurring:
- Roomba (iRobot): Traditionally relied heavily on camera-based vSLAM navigation (like in the popular j-series). This allows them to "see" landmarks and map your home. Newer, higher-end models (like the s9+) incorporate more advanced sensors and potentially different tech. Roombas are also known for their AI-powered obstacle avoidance (P.O.O.P. - Pet Owner Official Promise) on certain models, specifically designed to recognize and avoid pet waste and other common household items like cables and shoes.
- Shark: Increasingly uses LiDAR navigation across many mid-range and high-end models (like the Shark AV2501S AI Ultra - Buy on Amazon and Shark PowerDetect AV2810YS - Buy on Amazon). LiDAR creates highly accurate maps using lasers and works flawlessly in the dark. Shark also incorporates AI obstacle avoidance, though perhaps less marketed specifically for pet waste than Roomba's P.O.P.
Edge: LiDAR (often found in Shark) generally provides more accurate mapping and better low-light performance. Roomba's camera-based AI obstacle avoidance (on specific models like the j7+) is highly regarded, especially by pet owners worried about accidents.
(Caption Idea: Split image: Left side showing a LiDAR turret scanning, Right side showing a camera lens on a robot vacuum. Simple icons representing accuracy/low-light performance.)
Cleaning Performance & Pet Hair
Both brands offer models with strong suction, but their approach to brushes differs:
- Roomba: Famous for its dual multi-surface rubber brushes. These counter-rotating rollers are excellent at resisting hair tangles (both pet and human) and digging into carpets. Suction power varies by model.
- Shark: Offers powerful suction across its range. Many models feature a self-cleaning brushroll (like the AV2501S) designed to actively cut and remove wrapped hair. Other models use more traditional bristle/fin combinations.
Edge: For pet hair tangles, both Roomba's dual rubber rollers and Shark's self-cleaning brushroll are excellent solutions, significantly better than basic bristle brushes. Suction power is comparable on high-end models from both brands, but check specific model specs (Pa rating if available). Shark often emphasizes deep carpet cleaning with features like PowerFins.
(Caption Idea: Split image: Left side showing Roomba's dual green rubber rollers. Right side showing Shark's self-cleaning brushroll design. Focus on the anti-tangle aspect.)
Self-Emptying & Mopping
Both brands offer advanced base stations:
- Roomba: Offers Clean Base Automatic Dirt Disposal (often uses disposable bags). Some models (Combo series) integrate mopping, often with retractable mop pads.
- Shark: Offers various self-empty bases, frequently bagless with HEPA filtration (like the AV2501S and AV2810YS). Advanced models like the PowerDetect NeverTouch (AV2810YS) feature fully automated bases that also refill water and wash/dry the mop pad.
Edge: Shark often leads in bagless self-empty options and offers more models with highly automated mopping stations (washing/drying/refilling). Roomba's Combo models offer integrated vacuuming and mopping, but their base stations might be less complex than Shark's top-tier mopping bases.
App & Smart Features
Both brands offer robust apps for scheduling, mapping, no-go zones, and integration with voice assistants (Alexa/Google Assistant).
- Roomba (iRobot Home App): Generally well-regarded for its user-friendliness, smart mapping features (Imprint Smart Mapping), and integration with other iRobot devices (like Braava mops). The P.O.O.P. guarantee is managed via the app.
- Shark (SharkClean App): Offers similar mapping, scheduling, and zone control features. Some users report the app can occasionally be less intuitive or slightly slower than Roomba's, but it's generally functional.
Edge: Often considered a slight edge to Roomba for app polish and the specific P.O.O.P. feature integration, but Shark's app provides all the necessary core functionality.
Price & Value
Both brands span a wide price range.
- Roomba: Often positioned as a premium brand, especially for models with advanced AI obstacle avoidance.
- Shark: Often seen as offering strong features (like LiDAR and bagless self-empty) at very competitive price points, providing excellent value for money.
Edge: Shark frequently offers more advanced hardware features (LiDAR, bagless bases) at lower price points compared to similarly featured Roombas.
Roomba vs. Shark: Quick Comparison
| Feature | Roomba (General Tendency) | Shark (General Tendency) | Winner? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Navigation | Camera (vSLAM), Advanced AI Obstacle Avoidance | LiDAR, Good Obstacle Avoidance | Depends (AI vs LiDAR) |
| Mapping | Good (Imprint Smart Mapping) | Excellent, Accurate (LiDAR) | Shark (LiDAR) |
| Pet Hair (Brush) | Excellent (Dual Rubber Rollers) | Excellent (Self-Cleaning Brushroll) | Tie |
| Suction | Good to Excellent (Varies by model) | Good to Excellent (Varies by model) | Tie (Model Specific) |
| Self-Empty Base | Often Bagged | Often Bagless, HEPA | Shark (Bagless) |
| Mopping | Integrated Combo models | Integrated Combo models, Advanced Mopping Stations | Shark (Base Tech) |
| App | Polished, P.O.O.P. Feature | Functional, Comprehensive | Roomba (Slight) |
| Price/Value | Generally Higher | Often Better Value for Features | Shark |
Which Brand Should You Choose?
- Choose Roomba if: You prioritize best-in-class AI obstacle avoidance (especially for pet waste), appreciate a highly polished app experience, and potentially want integration with other iRobot products. Be prepared for a potentially higher price tag for top features. Example: Roomba j7+ - Buy on Amazon
- Choose Shark if: You value highly accurate LiDAR mapping, prefer bagless self-empty bases with HEPA filtration, want potentially more advanced mopping station features, and are looking for strong performance and features at competitive price points. Example: Shark AV2501S AI Ultra - Buy on Amazon
Ultimately, both iRobot Roomba and Shark make excellent robot vacuums. By comparing their approaches to navigation, cleaning, and features against your specific needs and budget, you can confidently choose the brand that will best serve your home.
Alex lives and breathes technology. With a background in consumer electronics testing, he loves dissecting how robot vacuums work, from their navigation systems to their suction power, helping readers understand the tech behind the clean.
Read more from Alex Thompson